© 2009 Jed

Ahoy mateys!

I’m going to have a go at being topical. Fancy that.

I was driving into work this morning thinking about how record labels can try and resurrect their shipwreck, blissfully unaware of the Pirate Bay storm approaching (pun intended). The thoughts had stemmed from a post that Guy had written talking about how The Streets (word to your mother – hat tip to Tim) were planning on giving away free tracks on Twitter. I’d made a comment on Guy’s post about live sales outgrowing record sales or something like that.

So anyway I was thinking about the whole industry and how it’ll all WIN or FAIL based on a few things… Here’s an attempt to explain what I think.

Labels

Labels need to offer more than the standard single/album. Now the chart has loosened its rules on singles and what you can and cannot include in the CD, labels need to get smart and start adding value. Music simply isn’t about singles and albums, it’s about the whole experience, man. Why don’t labels employ similar tactics to fancy advertisers and marketers? Sell albums that come in huge boxes filled with information, stickers, posters, access codes to secret sites, interview videos on USBs, rare tracks, live footage, branded memorabilia, booklets, additional artwork, karaoke versions, stripped down versions, remixes? You could probably charge £30 per box! Just add some value to the album and then see how album sales do. You can’t download added value from Pirate Bay – well, not in one go anyway.

Shops

Record shops are going to have to face facts; the only people that will remain record buyers are the ones that spend hours in little indie shops trawling through 70s bluegrass and obscure German techno. That is, unless labels get smart. I would imagine the obligatory five year cycle for vinyl being cool will probably help too – I still love vinyl, it’s a sound thing, but I can understand why people have moved on.

Bands

This is a great time for a band to start. They can pretty much control everything these days; they can market themselves, do their own PR, sell their own records, sort their own live dates, network with promoters… Everything! The best thing about the current music situation is that bands will make music for music, not for fame or money, and that’s the best thing that could happen for music.

Consumers

Consumers, from now on, will always win. Music hasn’t always been paid for, and just because some quirky fellas decided a while back that they’d sell sounds doesn’t mean it’ll always be that way. Creativity has always been in battle with business, and probably always will be. That’s why young bands talk about ‘not selling out the man’ and then a month later sign to EMI.

Piracy isn’t cool, but it does happen. Any music fan worth their salt probably downloads an album to see if they like it and then if they do they buy it in the shops the next day.

Now, I’m sure I’ve probably said some stupid things, I don’t work in the music industry, I’m not in a band (the world is missing out there) and I’ve never worked in a record shop, but I have collected music obsessively since buying my first Blur album. I love music, and love most of it (the exceptions being; comedy music, bad R’n’B, ‘donk’, gangsta rap and Blink 182).

Taking into consideration the fact that I’m only one quarter of the wheel, I’d like to hear what David Moynihan, Sebastian Mysko, Matt Churchill and Sue Keogh.

#Update#

Matt has stood up and declared his allegiance to music. I was really interested to see what Matt would say because he’s a musician as well as a social media Jedi.

  • Thanks for tagging Jed! It's a topic that I find very easy to get involved with, but very difficult to fully articulate when trying to make my position clear.

    @Sue it'd be great if Kristin would allow her fans to create content for her, such as artwork or posters etc as this too would make them feel included in the process

    Incidentally, social media Jedi is awesome - i now know what to put in 'about me' social network profile sections...!
  • Matt Churchill

    Hey Dan, thanks for the comment :-) I think it’d be great for fans to take tracks/art etc and play around with them. Radiohead have done exactly this, making raw sound files available to their fanbase for them to remix their own version. I think this is to be encouraged most definitely!


    This comment was originally posted on <a href="http://geetarchurchy.wordpress.com/2009/04/21/pirate-bay-a-fight-for-a-right/#comment-429" rel="nofollow" title="“Pirate Bay - A fight for a Right” (http://geetarchurchy.wordpress.com/)">The Seldom Seen Kid

  • Matt Churchill

    The thing is that it’s so hard to know where to stand unless you’re directly affected by the issue – as consumers it’s very easy to go ‘meh’ and find another source for the media you’re downloading whereas if you’re an artists, once your material is out there, there’s no way to rescue it. Why not bring those two things to a convergence?


    This comment was originally posted on <a href="http://geetarchurchy.wordpress.com/2009/04/21/pirate-bay-a-fight-for-a-right/#comment-428" rel="nofollow" title="“Pirate Bay - A fight for a Right” (http://geetarchurchy.wordpress.com/)">The Seldom Seen Kid

  • Dan

    Good points Matt. Who are Pirate Bay robbing from really? Only from the people who rob from the artists in the first place.


    As you say, record companies need to come up with a plan to become more competitive with their products, and not alienate themselves by resisting an unstoppable revolution.


    Great idea about letting fans add their own input. But how would you feel about letting fans do a mash-up of your stuff? It would be great for engagement, but where would we draw the line?


    This comment was originally posted on <a href="http://geetarchurchy.wordpress.com/2009/04/21/pirate-bay-a-fight-for-a-right/#comment-416" rel="nofollow" title="“Pirate Bay - A fight for a Right” (http://geetarchurchy.wordpress.com/)">The Seldom Seen Kid

  • Dan
    Should I be ashamed that I don't know who 'donk' are? We're not talking Wrestlemania here are we??

    Some really good points here Jed. When the music industry are talking about devaluing music by downloading pirate copies, it's bullshit really, because they created a false economy by opening distribution channels, and then closing them off to musicians. Now it's all about artists and fans online, and the record companies are outsiders.

    So absolutely, why not make them work for their money? Great idea about making CDs into collectors items by adding loads of stuff. And like Matt Churchill says in his response, giving it over to the fans and getting them to do remixes (within reason, of course).

    At the moment, they're not giving us anything with CDs that we can't already get online. I'd definitely buy it.
  • I think the model of giving away music for free is working well - but only for established acts eg Radiohead, The Streets who have already spent years building up a following. How it would fare for the young folk act whose only hope for commercial exposure is a brief slot in the Mike Harding Folk Show on Radio 2 or numerous small-scale festivals up and down the country, I'm not so sure.

    The Pirate Bay issue is interesting in that they expect to be able to copy all the music for free, but only seem to have the big name artists in mind, who will have plenty of other revenue streams anyway rather than relying strictly on album sales.

    One person who for some time has been quietly playing with the traditional model of releasing music is Kristin Hersh. She's been releasing tracks from her new album in return for a small donation, and people who subscribe quarterly also get extras like a free copy of the CD when it finally goes to print or a place on the guest list at her gigs. http://kristinhersh.cashmusic.org/
    So you are making a financial contribution but it's all going to the recording process rather than into a big pot at the end, with the effect that the fans feel more involved in her music.
  • You make some excellent points mate. I’ve been a bit disappointed in the amount of people that are unwilling to stick their necks out though… Even on some of the music blogs I read people have been really cautious to pass comment on this.


    I bet Jacqui Smith is reading this as we speak!


    This comment was originally posted on <a href="http://geetarchurchy.wordpress.com/2009/04/21/pirate-bay-a-fight-for-a-right/#comment-414" rel="nofollow" title="“Pirate Bay - A fight for a Right” (http://geetarchurchy.wordpress.com/)">The Seldom Seen Kid

  • What's with all the donk haters?
  • Great post! I agree, if Record Labels offered more with their cds, I'd be inclined to buy more cds rather than just downloading them off Itunes.

    Oh, and while I'm a fan of Blink 182, I hate "donk" as well!
  • Ahoy mateys | Rock Star PR http://tinyurl.com/dyob9j


    This comment was originally posted on Twitter

  • Just solved the issues with the music industry (http://bit.ly/sVXWf) tagged @guyclapperton @davidmoynihan @sookio @geetarchurchy @seb_mysko


    This comment was originally posted on Twitter

blog comments powered by Disqus